A Doctor’s Advice

My friend, Dr. Barbara Brennan, who gave up her practice because of her CFS, or Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, told me a very touching story about her last conversation with her gynecologist.

Dr. Brennan worked hard, and seemed to be inexhaustible until her illness stopped her in her tracks. In this medically underserved area we all work hard, and many of us looked to her as someone to admire, because she didn’t seem to tire of what she did day after day.

Barbara Brennan told me that there was one colleague who had told her to take a hard look at what she was doing.

Samuel Baumgarten was Barbara’s gynecologist for many years. He had delivered two of her children and when she came in for her annual checkup he always took time to ask how she was doing as a physician. She confided in him that she wished she wasn’t working quite as hard.

Sam had stopped delivering babies a couple of years earlier as his patients grew older, and focused more on gynecologic surgery. He had also cut his workweek from four to three days a week. He told Barbara that five days a week was too much for any doctor.

In his mid sixties, Samuel Baumgarten was youthful and always seemed relaxed and in perfect health. He was an avid skier, tennis player and sailor. He never wore a tie. He followed the Red Sox and gave the impression that medicine was important to him but never kept him from being a human being also.

The last visit Barbara had with Sam he had urged her to think about changing her situation.

“You’re working too hard” he lectured her. “No one is indispensable, not even you or I.” He looked very serious, almost stern as he spoke to his younger colleague and patient.

“People may say that only you can help them, but after you’re gone, they’ll say ‘She was good, but who do I see now?‘”

She often heard those words echo in her mind on days when fatigue started to creep up on her. She did start to think about what she might want to – or need to – do in the next few years in order to avoid burnout.

Two months after that appointment Samuel Baumgarten died suddenly while skiing down his favorite slope.  Barbara heard one patient after another say what a good gynecologist Dr. Baumgarten had been and in the next breath ask whom they should see now.

Barbara herself had to do the same thing, choosing to see Sam’s younger partner Sandra, who was ten years his junior and a nice enough woman, but not a mentor the way Sam had been.

His words came back to her often during the first weeks of her illness as she struggled with her guilt over not showing up at the office. They helped her make her final decision to quit her practice. And she imagined her own patients, one by one, wrapping things up the same way:

She was a great doctor, but who do I see now?

2 Responses to “A Doctor’s Advice”


  1. 1 drtombibey August 1, 2008 at 5:12 pm

    When I was a youg Doc, I had the honor of being physician to a gentleman who was a doctor’s Doc. He became quite ill and wound up in the hospital.

    After all he had done for folks, I thought there would be truckload of cards and letters. Instead, his room was much like any other patient’s- hand written cards from his grandchildren and a visit from his pastor.

    The only thing I heard from his patients was some variation of this recurrent theme: “Dr. Robin sick? Hm. Will you take over on me?”

    It made a profound impression. I love medicine, and work hard at it, but I take of myself too. As a result, I have enjoyed my journey not only at work, but with family and at play also.

    Dr. Tom Bibey

    http://drtombibey.wordpress.com

  2. 2 cathy August 4, 2008 at 4:21 am

    What a great post. But as a patient, sometimes we really do have a doctor, that even though realistically we must move to someone else if they are no longer available, we don’t ever forget them. In 1995 I had an oncologist who I would see for years and even though he is now retired, and has been since 2000, I still think of him, miss him, and yes I a different onc now, but he could never replace the original one.

    I love your blog.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Bookmark and Share

Mailbox

contact @ acountrydoctorwrites.com

RSS A Country Doctor Reads:

  • What Can Doctors Learn from Teachers?
    An article in The New York Times about Doug Lemov’s book “Teach Like a Champion“ made me think more deeply about what to do with outcomes measures in health care. Lemov has analyzed how successful teachers teach, measuring how long they wait for students to answer questions to how much eye contact they have to […]
  • The Difference Between Care and Cure
    My wife ordered a book a few weeks ago by Henri Nouwen, called “Bread for the Journey”. It was published posthumously and contains daily reflections. Nouwen is perhaps best known for his writings about the “wounded healer”. This morning over coffee, Emma asked me to look at today’s reflection, titled “Care, the Source of All […]
  • What Will the Doctor Do?
    In the near future, doctors will be the link between the science and humanity of medicine. They will listen and guide, while computers do the diagnosing… Oncologist James Salwitz writes about the Federal Health IT Strategic Plan in a nice piece on The Health Care Blog: “The doctor will no longer be the final fountain […]
  • The New Paternalism
    Doctors were once accused of being paternalistic. Today there is a new paternalism in health care: insurance companies are more and more heavy-handedly forcing doctors to disregard their own clinical judgment as well as their patients’ wishes by imposing “quality” standards through “pay-for-performance” financial rewards and punishments. Pamela Hartzband and […]
© A Country Doctor Writes 2008-2015. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given.